Cuban Cigars

The History of Cigars: Montecristo Cigars

J. Bennett Alexander Alexander's picture

J. Bennett Alexander

A tale of jealousy, betrayal and revenge published in 1845 was often read by ‘lectores,’ the readers who kept ‘torcedores’ (Cuban cigar rollers) entertained while they made the world’s best smokes. The novel by Alexandre Dumas was The Count of Monte Cristo and it was popular in Cuban cigar factories. So popular, in fact, that after Alonzo Menendez, who bought the Particulares cigar brand in 1935, immediately created a new brand named after the classic work. The Montecristo cigar was born. It has become a classic in its own right. The saga that followed might have been written by Dumas as the tale of two Montecristos. Montecristo means ‘mountain of Christ.’

From Literary Leanings to Launching a Legacy

After Menendez’s factory and the cigar industry were nationalized by Fidel Castro, Alonzo -- with seven dollars in his pocket -- and his family fled Cuba. The first stop was the Canary Islands, belonging to Spain, but since the Montecristo brand was sold there, Menendez and his son, Benjamin, had to create a new name. They chose ‘Montecruz.’ The design scheme was very similar to the Montecristo, but the ‘fleur de lis’ on the cigar band was replaced with a cross. As Cigar Aficionado has reported, ‘Menendez struck gold with the launch of Montecruz, an unapologetic copy of the Montecristo brand that his family had lost in Cuba. Made with Cameroon wrapper, a dark, toothy leaf that would soon prove a worthy substitute for Havana wrapper, Montecruz quickly became the No. 1 premium cigar in the U.S.’

A Cigar By Any Other Name…

In the 1970s, the company moved to the Dominican Republic and found a way to call the cigar ‘Montecristo’ again. Having acquired the rights to the name from General Cigar, the loophole was used to sell the Dominican Montecristo only in the U.S. where the Cuban Montecristo was banned by the U.S. embargo on Cuban goods. The factory is still operating in La Romana.

In the meantime, the Cuban Montecristo, led by the iconic No. 2, a Torpedo, became the most popular cigar in the world. In 2004, Cuba added the ‘Edmundo Dantes,’ a big Robusto named after the character who became the count in the Dumas novel. In 2009, the Cubans introduced the ‘Open,’ a line with a lighter flavor profile aimed at the European markets.

The Montecristo of Today

Today, the Dominican Montecristos are made by Spanish-French joint-venture, Altadis, S.A., which is also an investor in Habanos, the official Cuban cigar exporter. The Dominican cigars get great reviews and are generally more consistently well-made than the Cuban versions. They are generally milder as well, but come in greater varieties. The Dominican Montecristo White Series, with its Ecuador Connecticut wrapper, is among the best medium-bodied cigars on the market. The Especial No. 3, a Corona, recently received a rating of 90-points from Cigar Aficionado. The Montecristo and Montecriso Classic lines use Connecticut Shade wrappers. Other Dominican-made Montecristos feature Ecuador Habano (Epic and Monte lines) or the Mexican San Andrés wrapper (Platinum line). There’s also a fully Nicaraguan version called the Espada, made by Plasencia Cigars in collaboration with Altadis.

On the medium-full side, we love the Montecristo Monte line. It’s full of aged tobacco, with nut and espresso notes all contained by a luxurious Ecuador Habano wrapper. It’s available in a Robusto, Gordo (called Monte), Toro or Pyramid.

The tale of the two Montecristo cigars is one from which all cigar smokers can benefit. If you ever have the opportunity to smoke a Cuban Montecristo, try it side-by-side with the Dominican version. Let us know what you think. You might be surprised.

Featured Products

Related Posts

Cuban Cigars
Why Are Cuban Cigars Illegal?

Cuban cigars have long been an elusive commodity in the United States. Their monumental reputation and demand prompts many younger cigar enthusiasts to question why Cuban. Read More

Cigar Culture
The History of Cigars: Cigar Bands

Cigar lovers routinely debate what to do with cigar bands. Leave it on? Take it off? That might be as much as you’ve ever thought about that little, or not-so-little-. Read More

Cuban Cigars
The 10 Best Cuban Cigars to Smoke Right Now

While Cuban cigars possess an undeniable fascination among almost anyone with the slightest interest in cigars, it is important to point out the premium U.S. cigar market. Read More