Cigar Pairings

Best Bourbon & Cigar Pairings

Holt's Staff Cigar's picture

Holt's Staff

Cigars and bourbon have been at the heart of American audacity for generations. From gunslingers in the early days of the Wild West to executives who clang their crystal rocks glasses in a boardroom toast, a billowing cigar and a stiff whiskey seem meant for one another. 

Whether you’re trotting through the desert on horseback with a flask, chomping on a cigarillo like Clint Eastwood, or you’re puffing away in the back of a stretch limo with a mobile wet bar, you want a cigar and bourbon that display complementary flavors with authenticity. Bourbon and cigars already taste amazing on their own. But when you need to pair them up, here’s a rock-solid list of the Top 12 Cigar & Bourbon Pairings. 

#1 - Ashton VSG & Blanton's

Full-bodied and in high demand, Ashton VSG is drawn from a dark and oily Ecuador Sumatra wrapper that houses a delectable blend of premium aged Dominican tobaccos. Flavors display notes of earth, cedar, leather, and spice in a classic cigar that debuted back in 1999 and is handcrafted at the prestigious Fuente factory in the Dominican Republic. 

Blanton’s equally sought-after profile of nutmeg and spices delivers dry notes of vanilla with hints of honey, caramel and corn. This bourbon finishes with medium body and draws out a marvelous spectrum of sweet nuances in Ashton VSG. Together, the two reveal a luscious, woody marriage with savory depth.

#2 - Arturo Fuente Anejo & Angel's Envy Cask Strength 

Rare and exquisite, Arturo Fuente Anejo is handcrafted from the finest aged Dominican binder and filler tobaccos beneath a dark chocolate-hued Connecticut Broadleaf wrapper that has been slow-aged in a cognac barrel. The result is a medium-bodied treat that offers a luxurious profile of brown sugar, creamy spices, and cocoa with a buttery finish.

Angel’s Envy Cask Strength bears a glimmering amber color with a rich, reddish tone that has been finished in a Port Barrel. This exquisite bourbon emits a delightful panoramic aroma of smoke, leather, tea leaves, wood, and herbs. Notes of cherries, citrus peel, green apple and rock candy characterize an Angel’s Envy profile that measures up perfectly with the creamy, complex taste of Arturo Fuente Anejo.

#3 - La Aroma de Cuba Mi Amor & Woodford Reserve

Voted as Cigar Aficionado’s ‘#2 Cigar of the Year,’ in its debut year, La Aroma de Cuba Mi Amor is a medium to full-bodied Nicaraguan treasure, blended to perfection. Chocolate-hued wrappers from San Andrés embrace aged Nicaraguan binder and filler tobaccos. Notes of almonds, dark cocoa, spices, and black pepper are topped with hints of black cherries. 

Woodford Reserve, with its honey-amber appearance and strong aromatic blend of vanilla, tobacco, cocoa, and a hint of black pepper, matches up wonderfully with the mix of sweet and spicy flavors La Aroma de Cuba Mi Amor exudes. Chewy notes of cinnamon, cocoa, toffee, and caramel make Woodford Reserve an excellent choice for navigating the distinct transitions only a cigar blended by the legendary Pepin Garcia can offer.

#4 - Padron 1964 Anniversary & Knob Creek 

Padron 1964 Anniversary shows off a classic profile of cayenne and cinnamon with sweet, earthy spices. This top-rated smoke is drawn entirely from Nicaraguan tobaccos that have been gracefully aged to their apex to display a full-bodied, complex portrait that is still quite approachable. 

Knob Creek is a widely distributed bourbon that harbors more than enough character to complement Padron. A copper and amber hue glows with a sweet, woody taste and toasty aroma of nuts and grain. Naturally oaky, Knob Creek accentuates the consistent caramel-like flavors of Padron. Blend this pair of top-sellers on your palate for a refined combination that is full of rich accessibility.

#5 - Montecristo & Basil Hayden's

A creamy Connecticut Shade wrapper enshrouds a delectable blend of Dominican binder and filler tobaccos that radiate silky notes of cashews, coffee with cream, and a touch of spice in Montecristo. This legendary Cuban-legacy smoke delivers a mild profile that exemplifies the brand’s popular portfolio.
 
The understated brilliance of Basil Hayden’s effectively complements Montecristo. Its golden amber appearance and an aroma of tea and spices preludes a tasty amalgam of honey, pepper and soft caramels with a buttery finish. Basel Hayden’s is a light-bodied liquor with a gentle and satisfying finish that nicely accompanies a creamy and approachable Montecristo profile.

#6 - San Cristobal Revelation & Eagle Rare

If medium-bodied cigars are what you crave, San Cristobal Revelation delivers a sophisticated palate of creamy nuances with notes of leather, cedar, caramel, and black pepper that provide an exceedingly smooth and enjoyable smoke handcrafted in Estelí, Nicaragua. A milk chocolate-hued Ecuador Sumatra wrapper leaf conceals a luscious interior of Nicaraguan tobaccos grown on select Garcia family estates.

Eagle Rare encompasses a subtle mix of aromas, ranging from toffee and orange peel, to herbs, honey, leather, and oak. The taste is bold, but not overpowering, resonating with notes of almonds and cocoa. In this pairing, cigar and bourbon converge masterfully with a pleasantly lingering finish that is both sweet and dry.

#7 - Oliva Melanio Maduro & Bulleit 

Oliva Serie V Melanio Maduro conveys a succulent, medium to full-bodied Nicaraguan profile with delightful coffee and leather flavors, capped by spicy hints of black pepper. A lustrous San Andrés wrapper hugs an award-winning Oliva recipe with a balanced zest.
 
An alluring aroma of oak, vanilla, and honey with an infusion of spices forecasts the wildly popular flavors of Bulleit Bourbon. The taste is equal parts oak and smoke, with a dash of vanilla, culminating in a smooth, dry finish with the slightest hint of black cherry and leather. Bulleit and Oliva Serie V Melanio Maduro are an awesome follow-up to a meal of barbequed ribs.

#8 - My Father Le Bijou 1922 & Booker's

My Father Le Bijou 1922 is an award-winning recipe blended by Jose ‘Pepin’ Garcia in Estelí, Nicaragua from tobaccos grown on prized Garcia family fields. A Cuban-seed Nicaraguan Oscuro wrapper envelops fillers that radiate with full-bodied flavor. The blend manifests a plethora of peppery spices, semi-sweet cocoa, and earthy notes of espresso beans. It earned a 97-point rating as well as the ‘#1 Cigar of the Year’ title from Cigar Aficionado for 2015.
 
A deep, rich, smoky amber appearance is a sign of what’s to come with Booker’s. Its strong vanilla and caramel aroma is accented by a hint of charred oak, leading to an intense taste of fruit, tannin, and tobacco. The uncut, unfiltered approach of Booker’s generates a fitting taste to parallel the potency of My Father Le Bijou 1922.

#9 - Cohiba & Maker's Mark

The esteemed Cuban-legacy Cohiba franchise is handcrafted in the Dominican Republic to an exceptional standard. A diverse panorama of flavors is finished off by a distinctive, yet understated, sweetness thanks to a Cameroon wrapper and well-blended interior tobaccos from the Dominican Republic and Indonesia. Smokey spices with a bit of brown sugar burn smooth and easily.
 
Maker’s Mark reveals a brilliant orange-flame color in appearance and a distinctive aroma of caramels, honey and pepper. Maker’s is made with wheat instead of rye for a sweeter, less intense delivery. Savor lingering accents of caramel, cinnamon, malt, and vanilla with a creamy nuttiness in conjunction with the crisp spices Cohiba furnishes.

#10 - Rocky Patel The Edge & Wild Turkey 101

Go for the gusto with Rocky Patel The Edge, a beautifully handmade Honduran burst of spice. We recommend The Edge in the original, mahogany-hued Corojo wrapper varietal with its hearty core of Nicaraguan long-fillers and rich, peppery profile of cayenne, leather and coffee beans. 

The full-bodied punch The Edge can pack is best chased back with shot or two of Wild Turkey 101. The iconic, easy-to-reach bourbon is perfectly matured in American White Oak barrels for a deep, earthy char. A well rounded blast of vanilla, caramel, honey and tobacco are guaranteed to ring your bell and wake you up with a spicy Rocky Patel The Edge wafting from your mouth.

#11 - Romeo y Julieta 1875 & Buffalo Trace

An entirely well-known Cuban-heritage brand embodies its historic reputation with Romeo y Julieta 1875, a tasteful blend of Dominican long-fillers beneath a gingerbread-hued Indonesian wrapper leaf. The mild to medium-bodied recipe presents notes of toasted nuts, peppers, and coffee beans throughout a perfectly balanced finish at an amazing value.

Buffalo Trace is a magnificent companion with an equally revered appreciation. Its deep amber appearance reveals a textured aroma comprised of vanilla, mint, and molasses. Toffee, candied fruit and brown sugar notes receive a bit of welcome contrast from the cigar’s woody spices. Hints of dark fruit and anise emerge in a splendid marriage you’re guaranteed to discover for an accessible price in a number of places.

#12 - Punch & Jim Beam

We’ve been saying it for decades. Nothing tastes better than a ‘Punch’ in the mouth… except, perhaps, a Punch with a striking sip of Jim Beam. For the best match-up with bourbon, put a medium-bodied Punch Maduro on your radar with its toothy Connecticut Broadleaf wrapper. A hearty profile of peppers, molasses, and cedar readily characterizes the complex interior of Dominican, Nicaraguan, and Honduran tobaccos in Punch, and for a great price.

Among the best-known bourbons period, Jim Beam keeps up with a Punch Maduro in spades. Oaky notes of vanilla, caramel and toffee shoot through the olfactory senses as well as your taste buds with a sense of purpose and a touch of sweetness. Four years of aging in new charred oak barrels deserves to be savored with a proper smoke. One good icon deserves another, so indulge your inner lumberjack with this staunch pair.

It doesn’t matter if you’re out and about cigar-bar-hopping, or you’re camped out in the man cave watching a game with your pals, we guarantee our recommendations offer enough ammunition to stimulate your sweet tooth for bourbon and cigars all night long. Fire up with a pour that sounds like a fantasy come true for your senses. 

Featured Products

Related Posts

Cigar Pairings
8 Scotch and Cigar Pairings for the True Cigar Enthusiast

Scotch and cigars were born for one another, with certain combinations pairing up the best. Check out Holt's menu of the best cigars to pair with scotch.

Cigar Pairings
The Beer and Cigar Pairing Guide

One important, unifying characteristic cigars and beer share is the merger of science and artisanal craft many brewers and cigar-makers employ as they blend their products. Read More

Cigar Pairings
8 Wine and Cigar Pairings

The boundless extent of wine and cigar pairings presents an exciting challenge. A keen sense of smell and taste is required to register the most agreeable combinations. To. Read More