Search Content

Search form

Explore the World of Cigars
teaserimage-Old-Henry-Watchman-Toro
Staff Reviews

Old Henry Watchman Staff Review

Shane K. K's picture
Shane K.

Old Henry Watchman is worthy of total admiration if you’re looking to add new cigars to your humidor this season. After a breather to get groomed with new bands and boxes, the Old Henry franchise returns to claim its rightful place as the original cult classic among discerning aficionados everywhere. Old Henry also proudly brings a pair of new puppies to the portfolio: Old Henry Patriot and Old Henry Watchman. Today, let’s take the Watchman for a walk around the block for a full appraisal of its flavor, quality, and performance in a 6-by-52 Toro.

Named for an old pal of ours, the Old Henry brand is handcrafted at the esteemed My Father factory in Nicaragua, where world-renowned cigarmakers José ‘Pepin’ Garcia and Jaime Garcia began blending these hidden gems over twenty years ago. Old Henry Watchman follows the Garcias’ faithful formula: harvest the finest raw materials, age the tobacco for maximum smoothness, and let the most talented rollers handcraft every cigar using the entubado method for perfect airflow. The Garcias insist on triple-fermenting every leaf of tobacco and finishing every cigar with a Cuban-style triple cap.

When you crave a dark, decadent cigar that could keep you up late, the Watchman lives up to its name. A toothy San Andrés Oscuro wrapper embraces a bountiful interior of premium long-fillers cultivated on the Garcias’ estates in Estelí, Jalapa, Namanji, and Condega. Neatly nestled in 25-count boxes, the cigars wear cream-and-deep-purple bands with gold accents. Powerful aromas of hickory, birch bark, and vanilla bean set the tone after I remove the cellophane for a quick pinch test and a close inspection of a fresh Toro.

After clipping the cap with my V-cutter, I recommend relishing the cold draw longer than usual. The cigar’s dark, seamless San Andrés wrapper delivers exquisite sweetness as the cold taste settles on the palate, offering a preview of raisin, plum, and spice, with nuances of anise and pepper. Old Henry Watchman is a “thinking man’s cigar,” ideal for a long conversation or prolonged contemplation, thanks to its resonant flavor and density.

Upon toasting the foot with my soft-flame lighter for two minutes, the Toro fully ignites, and the taste shifts toward a bold portrait of espresso bean, black pepper, and wood. Despite its hefty profile, the Watchman rides as smoothly as a vintage Mercedes. Stay in the slow lane, though, and pause between draws. The deeper you dig into this dog, the more you discover. Hints of black cherry, black currant, and barbecue sustain the cigar’s spicy facade with greater intricacy in the second half.

In my ashtray, an immaculate pile of sturdy white ashes shows an expert assembled the Watchman from head to foot. Over fifty-five minutes have passed as I remove the band and close in on the nub, while bold notes of black coffee, spice, and dark cocoa come into focus. Old Henry Watchman bellows with a graceful crescendo before officially bowing out. This robust masterpiece merits a superb 95-point rating in my book. Pour yourself an old bourbon and sip it slowly with an Old Henry Watchman. It may be late, but a dog’s prowling is never done.

95rated

Featured Products